Thursday, March 27, 2014
As a Type Moon and Fate/Stay Night fan, I approached Fate/kaleid with much trepidation. Initially, I tried reading the manga years ago, but it didn't quite grab me, so I stopped after a couple of issues. I recall trying to read it shortly after finishing Fate/Hallow Ataraxia, and I had a huge Fate/Void in my soul that needed to be filled and Fate/Kaleid didn't quite do it for me.
I'm also not a big fan of Magical Girl animes unless it is Cutey Honey. Of course, had I stuck with Fate/Kaleid a little longer, I would have realized it was a decent deconstruction of the Magical Genre.
I say decent deconstruction, because it reinforces the tropes more than it deconstructs them. The main character, Illya, is a fan of Magical Girl anime, but when she is presented with the chance of becoming a Magical Girl herself, she is strictly against the idea, and is suspicious of anyone trying to forge a pact with her.
Even after becoming a Magical Girl, she is very reluctant of the idea, and feels silly and foolish when she has to change her clothes into ridiculous outfits in public.
At the same time, she uses the power of imagination, and can magically power up when in trouble whenever she needs to, as you've seen in a dozen shows of this type. Fights can also last two or three episodes, ending with a character's typical, "This isn't even my Final Form!" type moments.
Still, it is self aware enough, without breaking the fourth wall, to make these moments enjoyable.
Ultimately, however, the show is all about fan service. And I don't mean panty shots and jiggly breasts, which it has plenty of (or at least one pair of jiggly breasts). I'm talking Type Moon fanservice. To the point, I think this show would only be enjoyable to someone familiar with Fate/Stay Night.
There are cameos abound in the form of the Servants she has to fight, and about seven episodes in, Illya receives her true power, her ability to take the form of different Servants. It was a cool scene that had me yelling at my screen saying, "Say it! Say, 'I am the bone of me sword.....".
She didn't, and I was disappointed, but it was still an enjoyable scene to be sure, but again, only if you have any idea who Archer from Fate/Stay Night is. In this regard, sometimes I feel like I'm watching a spin off of Carnival Phantasm, more than an actual Fate/ anime. It feels like Pinky and the Brain to Carnival Phantasm's Animaniacs.
Also, I'm not certain how I feel about Illya's characterization. She's cute and mellow, and she is likable to be sure. It's nice that she isn't like most Magical Girl leads, being overly naive or optimistic. But she doesn't feel like Illya from F/SN, even a little bit.
In the original F/SN, Illya gets the worst of it in all three routes due to the nature of what she is. In the original visual novel she was supposed to get her own Route, but it was cut. So there was a large part of me, that wanted this to be the Illya route. But sadly, it can't really be considered that, even if she looks like Illya from F/SN, she is not the same Illya.
Tohsaka Rin, however, Illya's mentor and master of sorts, is exactly like her F/SN version. It's nice to have her familiar presence involved in the story in a more major way than I expected.
The first season ran last year, and a second season has been green lit, and will start in July. I find it strange this series will be the filler now between Fate/Zero and the new Fate/Stay Night anime that begins in the fall. It would seem better to space out some of these Fate/ series, as they cover a lot of the same ground as far as the Servant fights go. Perhaps they didn't expect a new F/SN to be made so soon.
In the end, this is a good solid series, that fits within the Type Moon multiverse quite nicely. It's also nice to have a series with the Fate/ characters with a more fun and lighthearted feel, without all the tragedy and heartache that comes from the more official branches of the universe.
Posted by lonecow at 11:19 AM
Fate/kaleid Liner Prisma Illya Impressions