number 1 and number 2 anime girl choices.
I'm sure most fanboys/otaku/haters (I lump them all together at this point) would say I'm a bandwagon fan who likes whatever is popular. I would take issue with this in a major way, as with both series, I just happened to stumble upon them by chance. With Eva, I rented a single VHS from my local video store and was hooked like painkillers. With Haruhi, my friend and I just downloaded a random anime to watch that had started that season. Again, hooked instantly. I actually take pride in my ability to instantly realize when a work of fiction is going to be beloved by all (or most). That is why I feel when people go on tares about how something is "overrated" and "only popular because they are told it is good" are talking out of their asses.
But that is a rant for another day.
In any case, as I stated Season 1 specifically is one of my favorite series. That is an important point, as Season 2 I do not include in that list. The first thing that probably comes to mind when someone mentions "Haruhi Season 2" is the infamous Endless Eight story arc. Eight episodes with the same storyline and plot but animated and voiced as if each episode was something new. I don't think any act has ever turned a fanbase against a show so rapidly and so quickly. And as annoying as Endless Eight was, that wasn't the main reason I didn't warm up to it.
After the first season I decided to read the books. The show follows the books nearly verbatim (in a wacky order of course); With one key difference. Kyon bitches and moans a lot more in the novels. Nearly every other sentence is about how Haruhi is driving him up the wall. So much so I found them hard to read after a while and stopped reading before the "Disapearance of Haruhi" novel.
When the second season got Greenlit, one surprising omission had been made to the staff. Tatsuya Ishihara was the director of the first season, and from what I can tell he was on board with Season 2 as well, however the Directing credit was actually given to Yasuhiro Takemoto. Now I had no proof of this, but I believed what Ishihara brought to the table as Director in Season 1 was toning down Kyon's personality from the novel. I say this because Season 2 seemed to follow the book version of Kyon to a fault. This was my thinking all though Sesason 2, as it culminated in the worst possible outcome of Kyon nearly punching Haruhi in the face. That scene in the book nearly killed the franchise for me, and I really hoped they would have omitted it in the show, but they didn't.
Other parts of Season 2 that left me a little cold was the absolute lack of development of some characters like Yuki Nagato, who had to endure thousands of days of Endless Eight without batting an eye. At this point, a character who I really liked in the first season, seemed like nothing more than what she was, a lifeless alien robot.
So up until the release of "Disappearance of Haruhi Suzumiya", the theatrical film version of the novel, my love for the Haruhi franchise was on shaky ground.
Now that I have seen the "Disappearance of Haruhi Suzumiya" on glorious Blu-Ray, I can safely say that, ladies and gentleman, Season 2, was all part of the show. Or perhaps a better way to put it, Season 2 was a necessary evil to set up everything for the movie.
Now I don't want to shit on Season 2 too much. It is still well written and has some really hilarious parts, but the characterization of some characters just went to a bad place. But I see now it was intentional.
The surprising part, given what I have just said about Season 2, is Kyon is almost instantly driven into hysterics over the absence of Haruhi. This is what made me instantly take a liking to Kyon again. There was never a scene of him going, "Alright! Finally the bitch is gone, now I can live my life how I want." No, from the onset he does everything he can to bring her back, to the point of nearly ending his friendship with his two lifelong buddies when he finds out Haruhi does actually exist in some manner of speaking (although he would never admit it, Kyon is clearly a "Hos before Bros" type of guy).
By the end of it, Kyon goes through a near "End of Eva" type of self revelation about Haruhi and the SOS Brigade. The whole film stands as a major piece of character development for Kyon. The Kyon by the end of the film is completely different than the Kyon at the beginning, and in a movie that is what I look for in regards to character development.
Also, there is another character that gets a surprising amount of development and screen time, Yuki Nagato. I don't want to spoil the plot, but she is the main female protagonist in this story and not Haruhi. On top of that, Endless Eight makes sense, or at least WHY they put the audience through it. They wanted us to feel a taste of what Yuki had to go through. The frustration, and the anger, multiplied by 1,800 times. We never see the frustration from Yuki in the TV series, but the culmination of those repeated days are very important to her character, and we see the result of it in this movie. Does that make "Endless Eight" a good idea? Probably not, but it does make it an interesting psychological experiment on the audience. Again, not saying I condone it, but it is interesting.
So that is why I say Season 2 is a necessary evil. It sets up the characters for this movie, at the cost of making a less enjoyable TV series.
However, I think it would probably be best to at least watch the first six episodes of Season 1 and the nearly essential episode "Bamboo Lead Rhapsody" from Season 2 (which is the best episode in Season 2 and maybe the entire series).
A question I asked myself after watching it was, how does this stand as a possible end to the Haruhi animated series?
I realize there are many more novels that continue the SOS Brigades adventures after this, but the way anime works isn't how popular TV shows and movies work in the West. Sometimes things just end in the middle of the actual story, despite the popularity.
Adding to this problem is the fact that Haruhi's voice actress, the irreplaceable Aya Hirano, has come upon some tough times as of late. Without going on too much of a rant, and it should be pointed out this goes slightly with my rant earlier about Otaku/fanboys/haters in that I think they are complete slime. They would want to see a woman's career fail because of what she does on her free time. If Kyon's voice actor, Tomokazu Sugita, had been caught having sex with multiple women, or even multiple men, he would still be playing Kyon without hardly any backlash.
Again, a rant for another day.
But back to my question. If this is the end of the Haruhi series, I think it would work well as a conclusion. Even though the Haruhi/Kyon relationship isn't fully completed, there is enough in the final scenes to let us use our imaginations on how it will end up. Still, since Haruhi isn't even in this film all that much, and there are a few loose ends left by the end of the film, I think at least one more movie would really seal the deal for me. But ONLY with Aya as Haruhi. No Aya, no Haruhi, no deal.